Player Ratings: vs Collingwood Round 3, 2017

Last time they played at the SCG, it was a thumping win for the Swans. But this time, a shocking first quarter was a bridge too far for the Swans, falling short by a solitary point.


B: Nick Smith, Aliir Aliir, Nic Newman
HB: Callum Mills, Heath Grundy, Harry Marsh
C: Zak Jones, Josh P. Kennedy, Jake Lloyd
HF: Oliver Florent, Lance Franklin, Luke Parker
F: George Hewett, Sam Reid, Will Hayward
FOL: Sam Naismith, Dan Hannebery, Kieren Jack
I/C: Jordan Dawson, Jordan Foote, Robbie Fox, Callum Sinclair

40: Nick Smith
Had a dirty, torrid time in the first half. Lifted in the 2nd, but was still soundly beaten for the night. 1st half, 2/10, 2nd half, 6.5/10.
36: Aliir Aliir
Shaky first quarter, recovered with aplomb. Steadied the defence early in the 2nd quarter and lead from the back with trademark intercept marks and dash. Was vital and lifted the team on his shoulders at times. Was immense in the 2nd half with a ridiculous 10 minute spell, repelling everything the Pies threw at him.
28: Nic Newman
Finished with 23 disposals, 1 goal, 10 contested, 4 rebound 50s, 4 tackles and 2 inside 50s. A damn fine effort in his 2nd game.
14: Callum Mills
Had his colours lowered in the first half and was uncharacteristically poor with the ball. Lifted in the 2nd half and did ok overall.
39: Heath Grundy
Had a forgettable first half, dominated by Moore and toweled up by White. Didn't have an opponent to body up to, lack of pace exposed.
31: Harry Marsh
He ran the ball well from defence and stepped up alongside Aliir in the 2nd quarter. But his disposal let him down time and time again. He's a better option than Laidler, but not a better kick.
10: Zak Jones
Had another one of those 'almost' games. Did a lot right, but conceded a costly free kick that turned into a critical goal for the Pies. Was shifted to Moore, giving away plenty of height, and shut him out of the game.
12: Josh Kennedy
A quiet first quarter turned into a monster first half with 17, finished with 33, 23 contested, 7 clearances, 3 inside 50s and a goal. His best quarter was the last quarter, but he turned the tide with Hannebery in the 2nd.
44: Jake Lloyd
He's racking and packing, but his poor disposal under pressure continues to let him down. He finished with 33, 23 uncontested and 1 inside 50, but 10 rebound 50s, and a few of those were just bombs.
13: Oliver Florent
Found it hard going, should have had a free kick right in front in the 3rd. Worked hard, 5 inside 50s, 1 goal and 3 tackles was a decent shift.
23: Lance Franklin
Several bright moments littered an otherwise down performance. In typical Franklin fashion, threatened to blow the game wide open, but treated the ball like it was soap. He still finished with 18 disposals, 7 marks and 8 inside 50s, but more importantly, just 3 behinds
26: Luke Parker
He doesn't look fit, and he's playing like he's not. 12 clearances, but shocking DE% just breaking even didn't really give the Swans much. Finished with 22, 18 contested and 4 tackles
29: George Hewett
Had a big 2nd quarter, but little else throughout the game. Still had 4 clearances and 6 tackles, and even though he had a few bright moments, he faded far too easily from the game
4: Dan Hannebery
Best on ground, should rack up the 3 brownlow votes. He was panicky and rushed in the 1st, fixed that, and was ridiculously good for the rest of the game. Finished with 31, 14 contested, 4 marks, 6 clearances, 4 rebound 50s, 9 tackles, 5 inside 50s and a goal.
20: Sam Reid
Could not work his way into the game. Didn't have a disposal in the 1st quarter (1 tackle). Finished with a goal, from a dropped mark free kick.
9: Will Hayward
Kicked 3 goals from 8 disposals. Great performance from the 2nd gamer and it'll do him a world of good. We've tried Towers, Jack and Rose, but I think this one is a keeper.
35: Sam Naismith
When the Swans were getting smashed in the ruck, and he was responsible for this, he lifted, dominating Grundy in the contests. He finished with 10 disposals, 4 marks, 31 hit outs, at least half to advantage, and 2 tackles. He gave the Swans first use.
15: Kieren Jack
2 goals in the 2nd quarter, a shimmy on the wing in the last, basically invisible for the rest of the game. Hit a chiseler pass in the 2nd half for a goal, which was good.
34: Jordan Dawson
One of the hardest games to debut in, ever. Collingwood weren't far off the tackle record the Swans set a few years back. Still, showed composure at times and clean disposal. His last quarter was pretty good too.
6: Jordan Foote
He's a better option than Cunningham, but barely. He gets in, tackles and doesn't mind winning his own ball, but his disposal lets him down. 3 clangers from 13 disposals, barely over 60% DE. DE doesn't even account for shanks or hospital handballs.
42: Robbie Fox
Another impressive game from the not so 'young' 2nd gamer. Got his first AFL goal, 15 disposals, 10 contested and 7 tackles.
18: Callum Sinclair
Start of the game, experience over youth, sure. 10 minutes in, a cannon into the sun would have been humane. He was terrible in the 1st half, possibly the worst player. He had 3 disposals with 0 DE%. How is that even possible? He was hardly better in the 2nd half. Cameron would have definitely been the better pick, but one has to wonder when too much youth is too much. 8 disposals, 3 clangers, 33.3% DE. Sigh.

Like what you’re getting? Want more Swans Blog, and the chance to have your input into our site and what we create? We have additional content weekly on our Patreon Service. This is your avenue, what are you waiting for? Sign up today and get more content like this.

If you'd like to support us, you can head over to our Red Bubble Swans Blog Shop, and purchase one of our hideously overpriced mugs, stickers or notebooks. Help keep The Swans Blog alive.

dismiss x

Since you're here...

... we have a small favour to ask. More people are reading The Swans Blog than ever, but we don't accept advertising, and don't want to do so in the future. Unlike many other news and media organisations, fan forums and fan media, we haven't put up a paywall, or displayed ads - we want to keep our content as open as possible.

The Swans Blog is an independent fan blog and community platform. Our content takes a lot of time and hard work to produce. We do it because we love what we do and we believe our perspective matters - because it may be your perspective too.

If everyone who reads our blog, who likes it, is supporting it, our future would be much more secure.

Make a one-off contribution →

Want instant access to the latest blog and news content from The Swans Blog?
Download our Android App from Google Play today.

Justin Mitchell

Justin is a passionate AFL and Sydney Swans supporter, and football blogger since 2016. All articles are of his own opinion. You can reach him by twitter and Facebook at @theswansblog

Melbourne, Australia

Subscribe to The Swans Blog

Get the latest posts delivered right to your inbox.

or subscribe via RSS with Feedly!